Question 14: Is it clear that there may be more than one possible treatment choice?

What the question is about and why it is important

A good quality publication will indicate that there is a choice about treatment. The publication should indicate that the treatment choices described may be suited to some people more than others, and that there is nearly always a choice of treatment, even if a full account of alternatives has not been presented in the publication.

Rating the question.

Your judgement will be important for rating this question. Consider the publication as a whole and use the hints to help you decide whether it has highlighted the issue of treatment choice for each consumer or patient.

Guidelines for rating the question:


5 rating:

A publication provides information about a new treatment for a form of cancer. The treatment is reported to be the most effective treatment available for the majority of people with this condition, and the authors describe the factors known to be associated with good treatment outcomes (such as treatment at an early stage of the disease and the absence of other medical conditions). The authors highlight some unpleasant short-term side-effects associated with the treatment and the possibility that a minority of patients may experience serious long-term consequences as a result of treatment, including the development of other cancers. A brief description of the natural progress of the disease and what is likely to happen without any treatment is also included. Other treatments are mentioned briefly and the authors refer readers to several other publications for more details. The authors conclude that they cannot recommend what would be best for an individual patient.

1 rating:

A webpage describes a single treatment for a skin condition. The page is written by a doctor and is found in the section on treatments on a national self-help organisation's website. The sources of evidence quoted are the scientist who developed and sells the treatment and the case of one of the doctor's patients who has experienced a 'miraculous' cure. The only reference to other treatment choices is the statement that 'all other treatments for the condition are associated with unacceptable side-effects' and the possibility of 'permanent disfigurement' if no treatment is used. The patient's search for a cure is described as 'torture' that led him to try other treatments that left him 'scarred' and 'suicidal'. The treatment is said to produce 'stunning and permanent results after a few applications with no risks or side-effects'. The author recommends the treatment as 'suitable for anyone' and 'bringing hope to all those who have despaired of finding relief from this devastating and unsightly condition'.